Teacher resources and professional development across the curriculum

Teacher professional development and classroom resources across the curriculum

Monthly Update sign up
Mailing List signup
Follow The Annenberg Learner on LinkedIn Follow The Annenberg Learner on Facebook Follow Annenberg Learner on Twitter

The Missing Link



From: David Gray (davidleroygray@hotmail.com)
Date: Tue Jun 18 2002 - 18:13:56 EDT

  • Next message: G1E2sons@aol.com: "Re: [Teacher-Talkmissinglink] oak trees and such"

    Hi. I worked on this earlier and arrived at the same solution as Gale and
    for the same reasons.

    In the process to check my probability prowess I also determined that:
         The probability that all of the salesmen were truthful is:
                    3/7 * 3/7 * 3/7 = 27/343
         The probability that all the salesmen were lying is:
                    4/7 * 4/7 * 4/7 = 64/434
         The probability that a salesmen was truthful is:
                    3/7 * 4/7 * 4/7 = 48/343 Multiply this by 3 to get the total
                    for all the possibilities of any one of the salesmen (a,b,c)
                    being the truthful one. Thus 3 * 48/343 = 144/343
         The probability that a salesmen was lying is:
                    3/7 * 3/7 * 4/7 = 36/343 Multiply this by 3 to get the total
                    for all the possibilities of any one of the salesmen (a,b,c)
                    being the liar. Thus 3 * 36/343 = 108/343
    My check for this is 27/343 + 64/343 + 144/343 + 108/343 = 343/343 = 1
    That accounts for all the possibilities.

    I always like to add extensions, extra, or what ever you choose to call work
    student can do that finished early. Here are some ideas:

    Using the same data, create another problem and solve it.
    Changing the data, solve the new problem.

    Here are other questions my mind entertains while wallowing in numbers:

    What are the odds that any of these 7 salesmen could identify an oak tree?

    What are the odds that any of these 7 salesmen would try to sell a tree of
    lesser quality than an oak as an oak tree?

    Which of the above odds do you think would be greater?

    And for a science connection: If 9/73 of the trees in a forest are oak, then
    what kind of forest might it be and where might you find such a forest?
    Assume this forest is in its climax stage.

    I must sign off before I nODDS off,


    >From: Colleen Keirn <ckeirn@cfa.harvard.edu>
    >Reply-To: Teacher-Talkmissinglink@learner.org
    >To: Teacher-Talkmissinglink@learner.org
    >Subject: [Teacher-Talkmissinglink] oak trees and such
    >Date: Tue, 18 Jun 2002 16:08:45 -0400
    >>At 3:04 PM -0600 6/11/02, Gale Greenlee wrote:
    >>> Hello: I wanted to discuss the various methods used to solve
    >>>the following puzzle. So to start the discussion I will present
    >>>the puzzle and then discuss the solution with anyone who is
    >>>interested. Here goes.
    >>>"Salesmen lie 4/7 of the time. We pick a tree in the forest, at
    >>>random, and ask the salesmen (three of them) to tell us what kind
    >>>of a tree it is. All three agree that it is an oak. The
    >>>probability the tree is an oak is 9/73. What portion of the trees
    >>>are oaks?"
    >Ok, I am going to take a stab at this. I have no basis, other than a
    >hunch, to base it on. I have no idea if I am right, by the way, just
    >coming at this on a Tuesday afternoon.
    >My process/guess:
    >The first bits of information are extraneous. The key information is
    >"The probability the tree is an oak is 9/73." That means for every
    >73 trees, 9 are oaks. So my guess is 9/73rds of the trees are oaks.
    >Just a thought. I'm really interested in this question now!
    >Colleen Keirn
    >Workshop Coordinator
    >The Annenberg Channel
    >c/o Harvard-Smithsonian Center for Astrophysics
    >60 Garden Street - MS 82
    >Cambridge, MA 02138 USA
    >Phone: 617-496-7686 / 800-228-8030 x1
    >Fax: 617-496-7670
    >Email: ckeirn@cfa.harvard.edu / channel@learner.org
    >URL: http://www.learner.org

    Send and receive Hotmail on your mobile device: http://mobile.msn.com

    Teacher-Talkmissinglink mailing list

    You may un-subscribe from this email list at any time by using the online form at the above URL. If you have difficulty using this form, please send email to Channel-news-admin@learner.org and our mailing list administrator will assist you. Our privacy policy is posted online at: http://www.learner.org/about/privacy_policy.html

    Teacher-TalkMissingLink Main Page

    Return to Top


      Registration  |  Graduate Credit  |  Other Workshops Purchase Videos  |  Broadcast Schedule

    © Annenberg Foundation 2016. All rights reserved. Legal Policy