ACPB Logo HomeChannelVideo CatalogAbout UsSearchContact Us


Discussion of Case Study Themes

Case Study 1 -- Twin Cities, Divided Lives

Relative Location
Location is one of the central concepts in geography. Geographers typically describe places in terms of their absolute and relative location. The absolute location of a place can be defined in terms of its latitude and longitude; that is, a mathematically established network of lines projected onto the earth's surface. In simplest terms, this system of measuring allows us to give a unique address to every place on the earth. Relative location, on the other hand, is based on functionality. This is an extremely powerful idea that implies that location is a function of spatial interaction, interdependence, and accessibility. The location of one place relative to another tells us much about the forces that lead to urban settlement and urban growth.

Twin Cities, Divided Lives focuses on the relationship between the cities of Ciudad Juarez, Mexico, and EI Paso, Texas. The relative location of Ciudad Juarez near the U.S. border helps answer a functional question: Why are maquiladora assembly plants located in this particular place? One answer: the area and its growing job-seeking population are ideally positioned for providing inexpensive labor to produce goods destined for the United States.

One of the most useful ways to assess the fate or fortune of a place is to look at its relative location -- where it is vis-à-vis other places. And, as the case study shows, the concept of relative location helps us understand a whole set of patterns on the surface of the earth, ranging from the distribution of parts suppliers for the U.S. auto industry, to the perceived strategic location of St. Petersburg in Russia, to the site of Lanzhou along the historic Silk Road.

Case Study 2 -- Operation Hold the Line

Spatial Perspective
The concepts of relative location, human/environment interaction, regions, and scale all combine to create a spatial perspective. To think in spatial terms, then, is to think like a geographer, to understand what is located where as well as how and why spatial variation can be identified across the face of the earth. The acquisition of a spatial perspective means that one has the ability to describe and analyze spatial organization -- the patterns of people, places, and environments -- on the earth's surface.

Operation Hold the Line challenges us to look at the regions shared by the borderland cities of Ciudad Juarez and El Paso by using the concepts of a spatial perspective. Relative location, for example, explains why Ciudad Juarez is located where it is and why Latino people and culture disperse across the boundary between the U.S. and Mexico. In terms of human/environment interaction, the prospects for future rapid growth of the settlements on both sides of the Rio Grande can be examined in terms of the less-than-careful water management that takes place as humans interact with this semi-arid environment.

The study of this area as the meeting of the regions of North America and Latin America -- one developed and the other developing -- helps us understand the motivation to migrate and showcases the unique issues facing people who live in a zone that combines the elements of two different regions. Using the concept of scale, one can organize a multiplicity of images into a complete picture of rich and poor communities coexisting in the same metropolitan region but not, of course, in the same exact location.

A spatial perspective grants insight into the reality of a borderland region. Through this perspective one can understand in new and profound ways both particular issues such as illegal immigration as well as broad patterns of spatial organization on the surface of the earth.

Home | Channel | Video Catalog | About Us | Search | Contact Us | Site Map

© 1997-2008 Annenberg Media. All rights reserved. Legal Policy.