Teacher resources and professional development across the curriculum

Teacher professional development and classroom resources across the curriculum

Monthly Update sign up
Mailing List signup
Invitation to World Literature


Experts' View: The Shock of the Old

An excerpt from The Bacchae, by Euripides
Pentheus and the captured stranger, whom he does not yet know is the god Dionysus

"Pentheus: Untie his hands. We have him in our net. He may be quick, but he cannot escape us now, I think.

So, you are attractive, Stranger. What fair skin you have, you must take care of it. No daylight complexion. No, it comes from the night, when you hunt Aphrodite with your beauty. Now then. Who are you, and from where?"

Daniel Mendelsohn:

"We know that this character is the god Dionysus, but Pentheus doesn't."

Helene Foley:

"He takes Dionysus, prisoner in disguise, as a mortal and tries to keep the women under control."

Brad Mays:

"What Pentheus brings is suspicion, is just simply an unwillingness to bend. So Pentheus has ordered his men to arrest this effeminate stranger and bring him to be interviewed."

Daniel Mendelsohn:

"That passage is the crux of the entire play in a way. You know, that's the first encounter between Pentheus the Boy King, and Dionysus the Boy God. Pentheus is kind of very attracted to him. You know, it's so brilliantly written, because Pentheus says 'Oh, well, you know, you have this fair complexion like women because, because you're a creature of the night.' Euripides is already showing you that Pentheus is obsessed with sex. He's so fascinated by sex, but he can't ever admit it."

Helene Foley:

"And you think you're negotiating with a human, but in fact you're negotiating with something far more powerful."

David Damrosch:

"Euripides offers us no simple solutions, no comforting answers, and at the same time it's a kind of a negative wisdom. Don't think logic is going to help you here. We have to sort of break through the very structures we put in place that keep the society together."

Froma Zeitlin:

"There's an element of mystery, there's an element of something which is bigger than ourselves."

David Damrosch Sums It Up:

Euripides' contemporaries seem to have been both fascinated and unsettled by him—rather as Pentheus is by Dionysus, in fact. In Aristophanes' comedy The Frogs, staged the year after Euripides' death, Dionysus himself journeys down to the underworld hoping to revive Euripides, as there are no good playwrights left in Athens. Yet he finds Euripides in heated argument with his great predecessor Aeschylus, who accuses him of having debased his art by focusing on low themes. Euripides proudly replies that he has taught women and slaves to speak, and "to think, to see, to understand, to love, to twist, to connive, to suspect the worst, to overthink all things"—to which his morally upright rival replies that the gods should have cut him in two before he'd done so. His plays are as unsettling today as they were to their first audiences.