Below are common ideas children in grades K-6 have about this
topic, compiled from research on children's ideas about science
(see the Session 2 Children's Ideas Bibliography).
Consider what evidence might refute this idea, and why a child would be
likely to believe this?
1. Animals are large, furry, four-legged land mammals.
Children often start with this narrow definition of the concept “animal” because
of the vertebrate examples that are most familiar to them:
pets and zoo specimens. Animals also include birds, snakes,
frogs, fish, insects, snails, worms, starfish, jellyfish, etc. Hide
Response
2. Fish, snails, whales, and robins are not subsets of “animal” but
parallel categories.
If children hold a narrow definition of the concept “animal” (i.e.,
large, furry, and four-legged), then it is reasonable that
life forms that don’t fit their definition are considered
to be parallel categories, even though they are animals. Using
scientific criteria – animals are multicellular, their
cells have a nucleus, their cells don’t have cell walls,
and they must ingest food – their definition of animal
can be broadened.Hide
Response
3. People are not animals.
The idea that people aren’t animals is likely to arise
because children have previously applied the term to animals
other than human beings – such as pets and zoo specimens.
Humans do fit the scientific definition of an animal: they are
multicellular,
their cells have a nucleus, their cells
lack cell walls, and they must ingest food. Hide
Response
4. Plants are small green things.
This is a narrow definition of the concept “plant” that
may arise because children have more direct experience
with plants of this nature – such as household and garden
plants. Tall trees, bushy shrubs, and woody vines all share the
same
defining features of small, green plants: they are multicellular,
their
cells have a nucleus, their cells have cell walls, and
they make their own food.Hide
Response
5. Seeds, fruit, vegetables, and flowers are not plants.
Children may not consider parts of a plant to fit the definition
of a plant. However, the characteristics that classify something
as a plant apply equally to the whole and its parts. Parts, attached
or detached, aren’t classified into distinct groups.Hide
Response
6. When children use words like “insect,” “fish,” “amphibian,” and “moss” they
are thinking of more extensive groups than those defined scientifically.
Before children learn the scientific definitions for different
groups of organisms, the definitions may be more loosely applied.
All things that look like insects are insects, for example, or
all things that swim in water are fish. Once children are introduced
to more precise scientific definitions, they can use them to
determine examples from non-examples.Hide
Response
7. Very young children do not classify groups systematically and
may use different criteria for every member of a group.
Children may recognize that a group of organisms are all fish,
for example, but they may place one individual in the group because
it swims in water, another because it has fins, another because
it has gills, and so on. As they are encouraged to look at one
characteristic only and “test” each object for the
presence of this characteristic, they can begin to learn to classify
systematically.Hide
Response
8. Classification categories are thought of as separate “bins,” not
as subsets of other categories.
The classification schemes with which most children are familiar
involve “exclusive” categories – this is, groups
do not share members. Biological classification is built around
hierarchical classification, in which one larger group includes
smaller groups, with each smaller group including smaller groups,
and so on. The criteria used to classify something into a larger
group apply to all of the groups that it contains. For example,
all animals ingest food. Fish, birds, and mammals are different
groups of animals, but as animals, they all ingest food. Birds
have feathers. Sparrows and hawks are different groups of birds,
but as birds, they all have feathers. The criteria used to classify
into groups on the same level (e.g., different vertebrate groups
or different types of birds) is when distinguishing features
come into play. Children may benefit from direct instruction
that contrasts exclusive classification with hierarchical classification.Hide
Response